• Home Home

New York homeowner urged to skip plexiglass for drafts: 'There's a much easier and cheaper solution'

"I hate to suggest your efforts and money [are] wasted on plexiglass…"

A window with covered glass and a yellow tape running across it, set against a plain wall.

Photo Credit: iStock

A drafty bedroom prompted one New York homeowner to purchase plexiglass to keep the winter cold outside. 

But when they turned to Reddit for advice on cutting it, commenters suggested a far cheaper alternative.

Here's what to know

In a post on Reddit's r/HomeImprovement forum, the homeowner said they planned to stay for just three more years and considered a replacement window frame too expensive. They wanted advice on avoiding cracks while cutting the plexiglass, which they had bought to tape over the window screen as another barrier against cold air.

The original poster wrote, "Winters in upper New York are brutal; one of our bedrooms is facing a gust of cold wind and to replace the whole window frame is $$$," before asking, "What would be the best way to cut plexiglass as it seems it can be tricky — any tips or advice would be greatly appreciated."

Multiple commenters recommended skipping the plexiglass process altogether, with one writing, "I hate to suggest your efforts and money [are] wasted on plexiglass, but there's a much easier and cheaper solution with shrink window film that you basically tape around your window and hit it with a hair dryer." 

They linked to a $6 Frost King four-pack of indoor window insulation kits.

Another commenter favored a magnetic kit because its clear covering could be removed if someone wanted to open the window. They explained in their reply that the magnets on the sheet attach to magnetic edging installed around the window.

A third commenter cautioned pet owners about using shrink film, saying it could not withstand dogs or cats trying to reach squirrels outside.

What can be done?

Some users took the OP's question at face value, instead of suggesting alternatives. One of the top comments read, "You can get the plexiglass cutting tool, which is basically a sharp knife on a handle, and score it a bunch of times with a straight edge, then snap it."

Another user chimed in to say, "I worked in a sign shop for years and this is the answer."

Other commenters favored a fine-tooth plexiglass blade in a variable-speed jigsaw. They advised keeping the sheet steady and taping the cut line, along with using a slow setting. One commenter warned that excessive speed could melt the plastic. 

Another commenter suggested having the plexiglass cut professionally rather than cutting it themselves, recommending, "Take it to a hardware store and have them cut it."

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider