One Michigan homeowner questioned an HVAC tech's recommendation to replace their furnace after a second technician could not verify the first company's report of a crack.
The homeowner took their story to Reddit's r/HVACAdvice community and wrote, "Turns out, I may have been scammed."
Here's what to know
In the Reddit thread, the original poster described the conflicting inspections and questioned how the first technician handled a potential safety problem.
When OP went back to review the report, they noticed the listed service date was weeks after the heat exchanger was allegedly found to be cracked, which prompted them to get another opinion.
The homeowner also said they were not advised to shut off the furnace or given a clear explanation of the potential danger.
They then wrote, "I also learned the original HVAC company was recently acquired by a private equity firm and that its technicians are commissioned. I'm incredibly disappointed and can't believe someone would potentially fabricate something like this to sell a furnace… Has anyone dealt with something similar, and does anyone have advice on how to report this?"
A commenter who identified themselves as a Minnesota technician said the first technician should have shut off the gas. But they also said cracks in the pictured location were a known issue with the homeowner's high-efficiency furnace model, so it's possible "he's not lying to you."
Another commenter explained that an articulating camera can make a suspected defect easier to find by allowing technicians to move around inside the furnace. They recalled using one to show customers cracks that other technicians had been unable to locate during second-opinion visits.
The same user noted, "I'm not saying you were or weren't scammed. But don't just take the second opinion's word because it saves you money. Call the other company back and allow them to prove their word."
To check whether the suspected crack could be demonstrated in the homeowner's furnace, one commenter recommended getting another photo of the precise spot identified in the first report.
For the homeowner, however, the first technician's handling of the potential safety concern remained a problem. They concluded in a follow-up comment, "I'm leaning toward getting another opinion based on all the feedback in this group."
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







