After finding white plastic fragments in an upstairs shower valve, one California homeowner began weighing whether it was time to replace their water heater installed in 1992.
A plumber suspected that the debris may have come from the aging appliance's internal fill tube, leaving the homeowner unsure of what to do next. They turned to Reddit's r/Plumbing community for advice.
Here's what to know
The Silicon Valley homeowner asked the Reddit forum for help comparing replacement options for their 75-gallon gas water heater.
The original poster wrote, "Wondering whether it's easier, cheaper, and more practical to replace [the] water heater with a new version of the tank type I have now or to switch to a tankless water heater that's supposed to be more energy efficient."

The owner said they wanted to keep using gas, but installation costs, efficiency, and maintenance all factored into the decision. They also wondered whether California's changing rules on gas appliances could affect the replacement timeline.
Commenters were relatively split on what the OP should do. One commenter simply wrote, "Once you go tankless, you will never go back!" before adding, "If you like a 40, 50, or 60 gallon water leak waiting to go off, stay with those bad boys!"
A commenter with the opposite perspective wrote, "Way too much needed to change to tankless for almost no benefit besides unlimited hot water," a line which prompted another user to poke fun.
"'Almost no benefit besides unlimited hot water.' LOL," the user laughed.
Other users asked about the OP's gas line, including one top comment, which read, "Another consideration of tankless is if your gas line is good enough for a tankless. Tankless gas supply rated needs are pretty high."
More background
In a follow-up, the OP described their three-person household, where showers do not overlap with one another or with laundry. They said they had initially chosen the 75-gallon tank to avoid running short of hot water.
The household's hard water and lack of a softener made maintenance another concern. One commenter who said they do this work professionally recommended annual descaling for tankless equipment, but overall, "With a 75 gallon, I'd definitely say go tankless."
For other homeowners exploring an upgrade, Cala offers configurable smart heat pump water heaters that predict your water needs based on your habits. Configuring a Cala system around actual routines offers a different approach from simply replacing the existing tank with another oversized unit.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.




