• Tech Tech

As Senate sends controversial BAAJA bill to House, environmental group summarizes biggest pros and cons

While the bill cuts through some red tape, many have expressed concern about environmental damage and Tribal rights.

The U.S. Capitol building is reflected in a calm pond surrounded by trees.

Photo Credit: iStock

A sweeping permitting bill just passed the Senate with proponents saying it could help build critical power lines faster while protecting households from rising costs tied to data centers. But the Sierra Club warned that those benefits come with provisions that could weaken protections for drinking water, wildlife, and communities facing dangerous projects.

Here's what to know

The 2026 Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act proposes a faster federal permitting process for infrastructure and energy projects. The bill runs more than 400 pages, and on Thursday, the Senate passed it by a 62-33 vote, including support from 14 Democrats and one independent (Sen. Angus King of Maine) who typically caucuses with Democrats.

In a Sierra Club analysis, the organization's chief program officer, Holly Bender, identified three promising provisions and four major concerns.

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission would gain authority to approve critical transmission lines after a year without a state-level resolution. BAAJA would also direct regional grid operators to plan together, prioritizing affordability and reliability.

Bender said planning, approval, and construction can together stretch beyond 10 years for power lines that cross state borders.

The bill would help keep those expenses off ordinary customers' bills by requiring data centers to pay for their use of the grid and connection costs.

Tradeoffs

Even when a project's approval rested on an unlawful environmental review or flawed Clean Water Act analysis, BAAJA would restrict a court's ability to stop it, Bender warned. That could make it harder for communities to contest harmful development.

The Sierra Club said BAAJA would shift responsibility for water-quality reviews from developers to states. States would have to complete those reviews faster while demonstrating likely harm and showing that mitigation would impose the smallest burden.

Bender said state wildlife agencies often lack the staff, funding, and expertise needed to carry out federal endangered-species consultations. BAAJA would nevertheless allow states to assume those duties.

Bender warned that developers could use the bill's protections against permit reversals to sue for billions of taxpayer dollars. Those same protections could also allow dangerous projects to keep moving forward.

She added that the provisions would not reinstate permits previously revoked for clean energy projects.

A fifth red flag Bender did not note is that many Native American organizations have expressed concern about eroding Tribal rights over land use, too, as Native News Online covered.

"I have long supported commonsense permitting reform and this bill includes many provisions that I support and even authored, particularly to streamline the permitting of transmission infrastructure," said Sen. Alex Padilla of California. "Unfortunately, it also contains provisions that would irreparably harm California and the 109 federally recognized Tribes who call California home.

"The bill threatens Tribal sovereignty, and I am deeply concerned that it could allow the destruction of ancestral lands, sacred places, and cultural resources without adequate legal recourse for the communities that have relied on them for generations. It also asks us to rely on assurances from President Trump, who just weeks ago said he would not approve any wind projects — and lacks the enforceable safeguards to ensure renewable energy projects will be judged and approved fairly by the Trump Administration and that oil and gas drilling will not resume off the coast of California."

What's being done?

The Sierra Club wants lawmakers to retain the bill's transmission improvements and consumer protections while revising its provisions on courts, water, and wildlife. It plans to take that message to lawmakers in their districts and congressional staff on Capitol Hill.

Bender pointed to the Trump administration's expansion of drilling and mining on public lands, support for coal plants, and cancellation or stalling of clean energy projects as the backdrop for those efforts.

She also faulted BAAJA's Republican supporters for voting to eliminate clean energy funding and tax incentives. Bender advocates phasing out non-renewable energy sources.

The extraction, production, and burning of non-renewable energy sources such as oil, gas, and coal causes air and water pollution that contributes to asthma, heart disease, cancer, and premature death. The resulting heat-trapping pollution also worsens extreme weather disasters that destroy homes, livelihoods, and economies.

Holding the industry accountable means addressing lobbying that delays cleaner, cheaper energy while prioritizing workers, communities, and household affordability over corporate profits.

"Right now, Congress should be doing everything it can to remove hurdles and barriers to clean energy, but we reject the premise that growing our clean energy economy can only come alongside weaker protections for water and wildlife," Bender said. 

"While orienting our organization and movement toward building the good, like wind, solar, geothermal, and batteries, we must be clear-eyed that these reforms can't guarantee the transmission and clean energy outcomes we desperately need with an administration hell-bent on stopping affordable clean energy from winning the race for the future of the electric grid."

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider