School districts including Los Angeles, New York City, and Chicago have considered alternatives to Google Search after the company said schools cannot disable its artificial intelligence-generated summaries without turning off Search entirely.
Here's what to know
According to NBC News, Google's policy has affected schools using its education software, as no Google-provided controls let students search the web while keeping AI Overviews disabled.
Los Angeles and New York City wanted to preserve Google Search access despite having paused AI use, the outlet noted. Some schools have turned to outside vendors' software to suppress AI features.
Educators said students can get answers to assignments simply by pasting the questions into Search and reading its AI summaries.
"Instead of listening to parents, educators and repeated requests from the nation's largest school system, Google has issued an ultimatum," New York City Public Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels told NBC News in a statement. "We're urging Google to roll back this decision and, if they don't, we will have to reconsider if Google search belongs in our classrooms at all."
Google spokesperson Laura Breen paired Google's description of its approach as giving schools more choice with an assurance that the company shares educators' goal of helping students learn, in her response to the network.
More background
For teachers, Google's classroom presence includes training and conference sponsorships. For students, it includes apps used for assignments and Chromebooks used for tests. That reach complicates efforts to switch to other tools, NBC News noted.
In 2025, Google agreed to an $8.75 million settlement over allegations that it collected Illinois children's biometric data through school Chromebooks in violation of state law, as the outlet pointed out. The company denied wrongdoing.
AI tools such as Google's rely on electricity-powered data centers, placing demands on the energy grid.
While AI has potential benefits, including helping to optimize clean energy systems, operating it can require substantial electricity and large quantities of water for cooling.
What's being done?
Exploring other search options would be Chicago Public Schools' next step if administrators cannot make Google Search available without its AI components, the district told NBC News.
Weaker protections against inappropriate content explain why schools often block search engines other than Google, the outlet added.
Districts seeking an AI-free search option would not get one through Guided Learning, a feature Google is developing within Search. Its purpose is to guide students through problems rather than supply answers. Breen relayed to NBC News that Google is working with educators to build those experiences.
Parents and teachers unions held demonstrations at Google offices across seven cities.
Others, who gathered over Zoom at former Google education leader Tracy Pizzo's invitation, heard her urge them to ask their schools to stop using Google's AI-enabled tools, per the network. An AI ethics evaluator, Pizzo previously led Google's education teams and left the company in 2022.
Decisions about classroom technology remain in districts' hands, emphasized Jack Kelanic, chief information officer for the Los Angeles Unified School District.
"We have over a million managed devices — we can change the default search engine literally overnight," he said to cheers, according to NBC News.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







