• Home Home

Pennsylvania buyer discovers 30-year-old furnace after offering $3,000 over asking

Commenters also raised insurance as another issue to address before closing.

A furnace in the basement.

Photo Credit: iStock

A Pennsylvania homebuyer offered $3,000 above the asking price for a house they loved, only to discover during an inspection that the furnace was 30 years old and the water heater was 15.

Beyond the potential replacement costs, the aging equipment raised a concern about whether the buyer could still finance the purchase.

Here's what to know

The buyer posted on Reddit's r/FirstTimeHomeBuyer to ask if a lower appraisal could help them negotiate a lower purchase price. Their concern was that the equipment's age might reduce the home's appraised value, leaving them with a gap they could not afford to cover.

"The ages of the furnace and water heater were not disclosed in the initial report," the original poster explained in a comment, noting that they had been told both systems worked.

The home was listed at $189,000, and the buyer offered $192,000. Though the house had spent nearly four months on the market, the buyer said a competing offer arrived the same day they submitted theirs.

Commenters suggested that working equipment would have little effect on the appraisal, with one writing that it was "probably not going to impact the appraisal value much at all."

More background

One commenter used a 1,700-square-foot home with three bedrooms and two bathrooms as the basis for negotiating estimates. They estimated it would cost $9,000 to replace the HVAC system and $2,000 for a water heater.

Another commenter said heating problems involving safety or operation could trigger repair requirements before closing on an FHA or VA loan. Conventional-loan appraisals, they explained, generally weigh the home's overall condition and comparable properties.

A commenter who identified themselves as an Ohio real estate agent and insurance agent said aging systems and deferred maintenance could lead to a lower valuation or repair conditions. They cautioned against dismissing the equipment's age.

Commenters also raised insurance as another issue to address before closing. Some carriers ask about the ages of furnaces, water heaters, and roofs when considering coverage.

What can be done?

One commenter urged the buyer to disclose the equipment ages when getting an insurance quote and set aside money for replacements. They also recommended having an HVAC technician perform a safety check before the inspection window closed.

The buyer responded: "Thank you for your insight! Will definitely be taking your advice, especially about the insurance. Very helpful advice!" 

In an update they revealed they opted against asking for both systems to be replaced. Instead, they and their real estate agent decided to request a seller-paid, one-year home warranty.

According to the buyer, the warranty would cover a portion of the replacement cost if either system failed.

The buyer's father believed the furnace could still have substantial life remaining and felt comfortable maintaining it and the water heater after inspecting them. The buyer described him as a handyman with five decades of experience.

"As long as the appraiser does indeed not consider its age to be of import, I think we're home free," they concluded.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider