The police report about a fatal Model X crash in Naples, Florida, in September does not mention driver-assist technology. Tesla, however, reported the system had been engaged before impact.
Here's what to know
Electrek said it has been investigating fatal crashes buried in Tesla's data for the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
It argued that the way Tesla has handled a Sept. 30 crash lacks transparency, even though the company reported the crash under a Standing General Order from the NHTSA, which requires automakers to report crashes wherein someone was hurt or killed if a Level 2 driver-assist system was active within 30 seconds of the event.
At 11:43 p.m. on Sept. 30, a 2025 Model X was traveling east on Golden Gate Parkway when it struck a traffic signal pole and overturned, killing a 50-year-old passenger. The 48-year-old driver survived with non-life-threatening injuries.
Tesla's telematics showed that Autopilot or Full Self-Driving had been active within 30 seconds of the collision. Its federal crash report stated that the driver-assist status was "verified engaged."
In a news release, the Florida Highway Patrol said the investigation remained open and omitted any mention of driver-assist technology, Electrek noted.
More background
Electrek said the crash was a prime example of "how much Tesla knows and how little it shares." The company has a video of the crash, an event data recorder, and other information that could help the FHP determine what happened.
However, the automaker redacted the software version and crash narrative in the filing along with details about the system's operating domain, labeling the data "confidential business information." Electrek reported that Tesla handles 99.9% of its reports that way.
Electric vehicles offer a range of benefits, from reduced energy costs to improved air quality. Meanwhile, driver-assist systems can reduce crash risk when used as intended, according to Tesla. But a lack of transparency could make consumers wary of these technologies.
"We're not saying the system caused this crash. We don't know, and that's the point. … If FSD or Autopilot did nothing wrong here, Tesla has the footage to prove it. It was happy to share data in the [Katy, Texas,] crash when it helped its case. When Tesla keeps the video sealed, people are going to assume the worst, and Tesla only has itself to blame," Electrek wrote.
Electrek asked the FHP whether investigators knew Tesla had verified driver-assist engagement. It also asked whether troopers obtained the company's video and raw vehicle data or received only Tesla's interpretation of those records.
"How many more fatal crashes will troopers close without knowing what Tesla knows?" the outlet concluded.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







