• Business Business

Michigan woman says false cancer treatment records put her life insurance at risk

The records attributed surgery in Colorado, CPAP treatments in Florida, and chemotherapy in Arizona to the woman.

A confused person looking at a paper.

Photo Credit: iStock

A Michigan woman seeking answers about cancer treatment she never received discovered a string of unfamiliar insurance claims — and a potential obstacle to securing life insurance.

Ten explanations of benefits listed care that Sarah Prentice, of Royal Oak, says she never received, leaving her to question why her records showed those treatments.

Here's what to know

Prentice's request for her insurance data revealed that some of the claims had already been paid, Local 4 reported. She has worked in insurance for 20 years.

Her insurer initially reassured her that she did not need to worry because it had denied the cancer-treatment claim. Prentice had called after receiving an explanation of benefits, or EOB, for that care.

Life insurance underwriters flagged the treatment history in September 2026 as Prentice arranged her policy, raising the possibility that she could be denied coverage.

"They said, 'Hey, we are flagging it. You could potentially be denied because you have been treated for cancer,'" Prentice said.

Prentice emphasized that she did not need cancer treatment and had never undergone it.

More background

The records attributed surgery for torso lacerations in Colorado to Prentice, along with CPAP treatments in Florida, and chemotherapy in Arizona.

A separate entity handled the billing; staff at the doctor's office told Prentice this when she contacted them, according to Local 4. Their records showed that the provider had authorized the care.

Prentice had not heard of Safemed, the Florida durable medical equipment provider she identified as the billing entity.

She also could not identify one local referring doctor, even after finding a national provider identifier number. Records tied that doctor to treatments listed in Colorado and Texas.

What can be done?

Prentice sought the records behind the claims instead of relying on her insurer's initial reassurance.

"So, I started requesting the raw data," she said.

She reviewed the paperwork and contacted the providers listed there to trace how the treatments had been attributed to her. Her husband is a financial adviser, and her own insurance-industry experience helped her know which questions to ask.

Local 4 reporter Kyla Russell also couldn't identify the local referring doctor. The station contacted the billing providers and referring doctors involved, including the Florida company and local doctor, but reported receiving no responses.

For others who discover records of care they never received, Prentice emphasized contacting the provider promptly and seeking a written correction.

"Reach out to your provider as soon as possible," she said. "Speak with them [about] trying to obtain a letter to redact this information."

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider