A Pennsylvania couple hoping to buy part of a 1925 duplex encountered an expensive problem beneath the floors when an inspection turned up a damaged sewer line.
The repairs could require jackhammering through a roughly 30-foot stretch of concrete, and the prospective buyers wondered how to negotiate around these extra costs before closing.
Here's what to know
Writing in Reddit's forum for first-time home buyers, the original poster explained that the Pittsburgh property was priced at $465,000. The couple wanted the sellers to cover the major repair costs.
The exterior sewer line appeared suitable for lining, but sewer piping beneath the house needed replacement, the poster said. A camera inspection had exposed cracks and root intrusion in the original pipe.
Workers would have to remove vinyl tile to reach the concrete, then break through it to access the indoor pipe.
The plumber's preliminary estimate put the repair at about $20,000. The sellers, meanwhile, had not reported any sewer problems in the 32 years they'd owned the home, according to the poster.
"How do you handle a negotiation for such a large project?" the poster asked.
More background
Beyond the sewer work, the roof was expected to need replacement in three to four years. Other inspection findings included asbestos tape in the ductwork, a couple of ungrounded outlets, and evidence of termites along an exterior wall.
The couple submitted their offer after the sellers cut the price by $30,000, the poster said. The reduction came after the listing's first week and an open house that drew no bidders.
The buyers thought the sellers might coordinate repairs across both halves of the duplex. The couple would buy one half, while the sellers would continue to own and rent out the other.
What can be done?
"First thing, get a real written quote from the plumber, not a ballpark, because the seller's going to want to see paper," one commenter wrote.
Lining the pipe beneath the slab might avoid the need to break up the concrete, another commenter noted. They recommended asking two plumbers about that option and getting quotes to establish a clearer repair cost.
An Ohio-based commenter who identified themselves as a real estate and insurance agent said the sellers could complete the work before closing or put money in a repair escrow. A price reduction or closing credit were other possibilities.
They advised the couple to consult their lender about any borrowing rules that might limit seller credits.
"If they don't go for paying for the repairs, we will walk, as we only made an offer on the house after the $30k price drop. Adding these repairs in would take the house price back above our limit," the original poster explained.
Where can I learn more?
Other buyers have run into sewer trouble during inspections, including in older homes:
• A Tennessee buyer expecting a turnkey home discovered a crushed sewer pipe during an inspection.
• A Pennsylvania homeowner paid $8,000 for a sewer line that ran beneath a neighbor's yard.
• A buyer considering a century-old home received repeated advice to get a sewer scope.
• An inspector spotted a hidden sewer line at a flipped house, prompting concerns that it was abandoned.
• A North Carolina renter buying a 1955 house weighed a $250 sewer scope as commenters urged action.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







