• Home Home

New Jersey parents find lead in their 1900 home after DIY tests came back negative

"How can you keep track of all the contaminated parts?"

Paint testing positive for lead.

Photo Credit: Image © 2024 by Minnesota Historical Society Heritage Preservation Department is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0

A New Jersey family thought their century-old home was free of lead after a series of do-it-yourself tests came back negative.

However, their one-year-old daughter's blood screening prompted more thorough testing, which revealed contamination in several areas of the house.

Here's what to know

In a Reddit post, the parent asked how to clean clothing, books, and floors after discovering lead in their home, built in 1900.

"Would water and soap do?" the parent asked. "How can you keep track of all the contaminated parts?"

Their daughter's finger-prick screening prompted the first-time homebuyers to pull together money for more thorough testing. They had previously checked surfaces and water with kits bought online, all of which returned negative results.

Testing found lead in a heavily traveled part of the husband's workshop and in chipped sections of an under-stairs closet. Window molding also tested positive despite having a newer coat of paint.

The parent said books in the room where their daughter spent time had previously been stored in another small closet that tested positive.

More background

The parent said they hurried through the home purchase, assuming previous occupants had already dealt with toxic substances. The renovated home had also been used as an office before the family bought it.

The parent reported no major demolition but worried that walking on the stairs might have disturbed material above the stored jackets. 

In a follow-up, the parent clarified that their daughter had received only a finger-prick screening, with no venous blood test performed. They also reported that the pediatrician had asked about toys purchased online as a possible source of exposure.

What can be done?

One commenter recommended asking the doctor for a blood draw. They also suggested checking for lead in the plumbing by testing water left standing in the pipes. In reply, the parent said they planned another water test and had already bought water filters and a softener.

Commenters also suggested professional help alongside household measures such as removing shoes indoors and mopping more often. One advised choosing a lead-testing company that does not offer remediation services.

Another warned that renovations could create additional dust unless handled professionally — a concern for the parent, who had initially believed the affected areas looked manageable without outside help.

Where can I learn more?

Other families and homeowners have also struggled to identify lead hazards and figure out what to do next. 

• In New England, a parent suspected a worn closet rod contributed to their 1-year-old's lead scare.

• A new homeowner learned one NSF label didn't prove a filter could remove lead.

• In Dunkirk, New York, a homeowner remained unsure whether tap water was lead-free amid missed deadlines.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider