An Ohio homeowner challenged a $382 water bill after he said officials told him he owed for 20 years of undercounted use, raising questions about who should pay for problems with aging equipment.
Here's what to know
Some LaGrange households saw their water charges more than double in November, leading residents to contact News 5.
The village uncovered inaccurate readings while replacing roughly 30-year-old water meters. Mayor Gary Kincannon said those inaccuracies accounted for at least part of the increase.
Longtime resident Mark Varady's $382 bill was more than 180% above his usual monthly average of about $130.
"Over the last period of 20 years or so, they said I used 22,000 gallons that wasn't paid for," Varady told News 5. "It raised my bill to $382 for this month."
LaGrange resident Dennis Smith reported a similar increase, with bills showing charges of $114 in October and $297 in November. His family has lived in the same LaGrange house for more than five decades.
More background
Mayor Kincannon said the effort to upgrade LaGrange's aging meters had been underway for about five years. The village's water comes from the Rural Lorain County Water Authority, and residents are billed according to their consumption, News 5 reported.
Kincannon told News 5 that some households' sharp increases reflected previously uncounted water use. He said the village had covered a gap in November 2024 by transferring $140,000 from its general fund.
Kincannon noted the impact varied by household. He suggested that some residents may have seen little change, while others received substantially higher bills.
"That small degree of inaccuracy has brought on this big change," Smith said. "And if they've known that, why wasn't it corrected?"
What's being done?
Residents could pay the additional costs in installments under a measure the Village Council is considering, News 5 reported.
Varady questioned why residents should bear costs caused by faulty village equipment.
"What legal authority do they have to do this?" he said. "I don't see one."
Council was scheduled to discuss the options at its Nov. 19 meeting. Kincannon said officials were still weighing possible responses, including having the village absorb the costs.
"Hindsight rather than foresight," he observed. "We should've been more proactive rather than reactive. That's a lot of the problem here."
Where can I learn more?
Faulty meters and charges for previously uncounted water have sparked billing disputes in other communities, too.
• In Nahant, Massachusetts, free water meter upgrades could mean higher bills for unchanged consumption.
• In Odessa, Texas, officials fought water bill refunds as hundreds said new meters quadrupled charges.
• In Los Angeles, a $9,200 water bill followed three years with a broken meter.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







