• Business Business

Jaguar Land Rover sought $550,000 from BYD but now risks $55,000 hourly fines over seized files

The court approved the August seizure without giving BYD an opportunity to object beforehand.

A Land Rover Defender.

Photo Credit: iStock

Jaguar Land Rover's effort to gather evidence against a rival has taken a costly turn after a Dutch court ordered the automaker to have seized BYD files destroyed.

Delayed compliance could cost the company €50,000 ($55,385) an hour.

Here's what to know

A preliminary ruling dated Nov. 11 reversed an August evidence seizure at BYD's offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp.

Judge H.F.R. van Heemstra of the District Court of The Hague issued the decision, according to CarNewsChina, citing reporting by Dutch auto publication AutoWeek via ANP.

Jaguar Land Rover, also known as JLR, suspected BYD of reverse-engineering the Land Rover Defender and alleged that the Ti 7 copied its exterior design. BYD markets the Ti 7 in China as the Fang Cheng Bao Tai 7.

JLR never received the seized records directly; they remained with an independent custodian appointed by the court.

JLR's intellectual property infringement allegations against the Ti 7 remain unresolved following the decision to overturn the evidence seizure.

More background

The court approved the August seizure without giving BYD an opportunity to object beforehand, using a procedure known as ex parte.

BYD later argued that the seizure was too broad because it included proprietary research and development records unrelated to the dispute.

Defender-related records were among the seized files, alongside technical and financial data and plans for the Ti 7's launch.

The court said JLR could support its design allegations without those records.

BYD had not yet sold the Ti 7 in the EU, so the court found no need for the records to estimate potential damages either.

What's being done?

Formal service of the ruling starts the clock: JLR then has 24 hours to instruct the bailiff or court-appointed custodian to destroy the seized material. 

Missing that deadline triggers the hourly penalty.

The fines are capped at €500,000, or approximately $553,850. At €50,000 an hour, JLR could hit that limit after just 10 hours of failure to comply with the ruling.

The court also set a separate deadline for proof of destruction — JLR must give BYD independent confirmation within 24 hours after the records are destroyed.

No one outside BYD, including JLR and the custodian, may retain access to the records.

The court provisionally found that BYD had complied with the initial seizure order and rejected JLR's demand for €500,000 ($550,000) in penalties against the company.

Where can I learn more?

Jaguar and BYD are also pursuing new vehicles and market opportunities. These stories cover Jaguar's electric launch, BYD's expansion plans, and a BYD sighting in Ontario.

• Jaguar's $130,500 electric Type 01 has arrived, dividing fans over the brand's all-electric bet.

• EU tariffs are pushing BYD toward Hungary, with three more European factories planned.

• In Ontario, a BYD Sealion appeared on Highway 407 with manufacturer plates, fueling debut speculation.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider