• Outdoors Outdoors

Michigan owner says potential $150,000-plus fine for cutting 26 trees would sink rental project

East Lansing staff reported finding additional stumps beneath piles of felled trees.

A pile of cut logs.

Photo Credit: iStock

Dozens of mature trees have been cut down in East Lansing, Michigan, leaving environmental losses that could take decades to reverse. The property owner could face a fine exceeding $150,000.

Here's what to know

Mature hickories and red oaks were among the trees cut down on East Coleman Road. City forestry staff identified 26 removals at the properties, according to East Lansing Info.

The trees had a combined diameter of 747 inches, resulting in a proposed $149,400 penalty under a city ordinance, according to City Clerk Emily Gordon's report. The ordinance charges $200 per inch for illegally removed trees measuring at least four inches across.

The fine could grow. On Oct. 6, the City Council postponed a decision after East Lansing staff reported finding additional stumps beneath piles of felled trees.

Brandon Green, a real estate agent and co-owner of the properties, blamed a misunderstanding with Principal Planner Landon Bartley for the tree removal.

Bartley said he did not know Green intended to remove trees. Green had written in an April 30 email, "We also have a company doing some tree-work along the property line in the next few weeks, which I wanted to notify them of," but the two disagreed about what that communication conveyed. Green also disputed the additional stump findings, saying some trees had been removed before he purchased the properties.

More background

An East Lansing staff report described consequences for the surrounding community, including reduced stormwater absorption, loss of wildlife habitat, and diminished air-quality benefits.

Using the Michigan Tree Valuation Guide, the staff report valued the original 26 trees at between $148,276.74 and $186,435.74.

City Clerk Emily Gordon's report explained that removing trees at least four inches in diameter requires a permit. To qualify for an exemption, a property must meet all three conditions: residential zoning, an area of no more than two acres, and use for single- or two-family homes.

Green said he is seeking permits for rentals and plans to turn a warehouse into living space, East Lansing Info reported. He described his business as turning properties that need work into affordable housing, with 17 conversions across Greater Lansing since 2017.

City Attorney Carlito Young said differing interpretations of the communications do not change the ordinance's requirements.

What's being done?

Green proposed donating the firewood from the removed trees to a nonprofit or East Lansing parks. He also proposed planting at least 26 oak and hickory seedlings on the properties and at locations selected by the city.

He also proposed organizing a music and art fundraiser festival every two years to promote tree planting.

Mayor Pro Tem Chuck Grigsby and Councilmember Steve Whelan favored a response that could serve as a teaching opportunity. Councilmember Kerry Ebersole Singh also sought an alternative.

"A six-figure fine is steep, it's real, but 26 trees … is significant as well," Singh said. "I will say, whether it should be part of this equation or not in this quasi-judicial process we're embarking upon is, you know, if we were putting affordable housing in there … I'd probably feel more forgiving about some of the trees that we lost.

"I would love for you guys to convene and perhaps come back to us with another option away from the top figure," Singh said.

Mayor Erik Altmann, however, warned against weakening the ordinance's ability to deter future violations.

"Do we care whether this happens again?" Altmann asked. "Because if all you have to do is come in and say 'I'm responsible' and you get a deal, then it's going to happen again."

Green plans to challenge the penalties in court, saying the properties' future is at stake.

"We plan on fighting these fines and taking it to whatever court necessary and executing our plan and keeping the properties long-term. If a high court holds us to the fines they are trying to impose we would have to sell off the properties. No chance we can pay a six-figure fine."

Where can I learn more?

Other communities have faced similar disputes over tree removal, from development plans to neighborhood safety concerns.

• North Carolina neighbors say two century-old heritage oaks face removal for a new home.

• A Florida county cut down 62 oaks over buckled sidewalks, drawing complaints from residents.

• A homeowner says the state illegally removed landscaping and trees during a road-widening project.

• In California, a utility removed a dangerous tree but left a flammable mess behind.

• A Florida HOA demands homeowners replace dead swale trees, but residents dispute responsibility.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider