• Home Home

Pennsylvania homeowner's yard caves in, but sinkhole insurance won't cover the water main damage

"We literally had four inches of water through the entire basement."

A large circular sinkhole in a garden surrounded by shrubs and mulch.

Photo Credit: iStock

A Pennsylvania homeowner who thought his sinkhole insurance would protect his family is now facing costly repairs after his yard collapsed and water poured into his house.

Here's what to know

The ground outside Bradley Stepp's home in Coplay, Pennsylvania, gave way on October 25 while he was outside, according to WFMZ.

"I was relaxing out front, and the yard just kind of disappeared in front of me, and I see a whirlpool of water, and it all was just flowing into my house," Stepp said.

Stepp said the cause of the collapse led his insurance company to reject his claim. He had sinkhole coverage with the insurer and had initially expected it to help pay for the damage.

The company attributed the soil washout to a broken water main, which fell outside the policy's coverage for naturally occurring limestone erosion.

More background

The cleanup included cutting several inches from the drywall and removing water, mud, and damaged materials from the home. Stepp told WFMZ he worked quickly after the flooding to prevent mold growth.

"We literally had four inches of water through the entire basement. You can see the water line as you walk around," he said.

Stepp also had to remove the basement's linoleum flooring.

Stepp asked the local water authority whether it could provide financial assistance or had a department to handle claims after his insurer denied coverage.

His family was left to cover the damage themselves after the authority told him no help was available, he said.

What's being done?

Stepp has launched a GoFundMe for his family's benefit while he explores his legal options. He also said he would need a lawyer willing to represent him pro bono.

"We're out of money, and there's no way I'm going to be able to figure out how to pay for a lawyer on top of this," Stepp said, according to WFMZ.

Municipalities have protections under Pennsylvania's Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act. In a case like this, homeowners must prove that government negligence caused the damage and file a claim within six months.

The water authority had not replied to WFMZ's request for comment, which the outlet attributed to the Veterans Day holiday.

Stepp hopes his family's experience will alert other homeowners to the challenges they could face.

"I want to be the voice for the future people that have to deal with this," he said. "There's no protection for anybody from an event like this."

Where can I learn more?

Other homeowners have run into trouble with sinkholes, damaged pipes, and gaps in water-damage coverage. 

• In Massachusetts, two sinkholes exposed a buried 7-foot pipe, with repairs potentially taking weeks.

• A Los Angeles water main rupture opened a sinkhole that swallowed a Spectrum van.

• Houston officials called a 16-foot well a private problem after a homeowner flagged it.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider