• Outdoors Outdoors

Massachusetts residents pack hearing to fight developer's bid to lift water protections

"I think it's really important we preserve this aquifer as a future drinking water source."

A microphone in focus with a blurred background of people in a room.

Photo Credit: iStock

Concerns about their community's future drinking water supply brought residents to a packed hearing in Greenfield, Massachusetts, where they opposed removing protections near an inactive well, according to The Recorder.

Here's what to know

First Generation Investment Group paid $270,000 in 2025 for 30 acres at the end of Lunt Drive. 

The company wants Greenfield to remove the Leary Well area's Water Supply Protection District.

Company co-founder Igor Komerzan maintained that the current zoning overlay allows one house on the property, or potentially three with a cul-de-sac. 

Removing it would permit more housing and make the lots less expensive to buyers, he asserted. The final number of homes remains undetermined.

Residents argued that protecting the groundwater beneath the property could help meet future water needs, regardless of whether the well is currently in use.

"The issue is not the well, it's the aquifer," resident Steve Alves objected. "Is it worth the risk of removing this protection district?"

More background

In a letter to the boards, Department of Public Works Director Paul Newell expressed no objection to removing the district, explaining that development of the Leary Well was never completed. 

The well's isolated location would also make connecting it to city infrastructure costly.

DPW representatives said the city's daily water use is 2.2 million gallons, compared with a capacity of 3.5 million gallons. Newell wrote that protections for active municipal water sources would remain in place.

Resident Susan Olmsted pointed to data from the Source Water Assessment & Protection program run by the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection, saying it identifies high susceptibility for the city's groundwater sources and water system. 

She argued that the overlay limits large-scale development that could affect the aquifer.

"Our current water sources have high vulnerability to contaminants," Olmsted noted. "I think it's really important we preserve this aquifer as a future drinking water source."

What's being done?

The Economic Development Committee and Planning Board took no votes, seeking more time to deliberate and for the DPW to locate a 1981 Tighe & Bond report that could clarify conditions around the well, per The Recorder.

Residents requested developer-funded hydrogeologic testing or consideration of other locations.

Planning Director Ella Wise said the property had been labeled undevelopable because it lacked frontage, a problem that extending the road could resolve. The existing overlay still allows housing, she confirmed.

Wise said removing the overlay would let the city recommend cluster development, with smaller lots grouped together and potentially half the parcel required to remain open space. She also observed that the current protections do not bar forest clear-cutting.

Former Mayor Bill Martin said additional homes would help meet housing goals and increase tax revenue. The proposal is expected to return to both boards before reaching City Council.

Precinct 2 Councilor Rachel Gordon emphasized that residents would have more opportunities to weigh in as the proposal moves through city review.

"This is the start of a conversation, not the end of the conversation," she stated. "There are going to be many more opportunities to make your voices heard."

Where can I learn more?

Other communities in Massachusetts and Connecticut are also weighing development and infrastructure plans against concerns about water supplies and public land. These stories cover housing near wells, well protection rules, and proposed increases in water withdrawal.

• Residents warn a Connecticut housing plan threatens wells supplying 70% of a town's water.

• Amherst, Massachusetts, adopted private well protection buffers in its clean energy siting bylaw.

• Massachusetts lawmakers question an MWRA proposal for 20 million more gallons daily from Quabbin.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider