A homeowner investigating a previous owner's water heater installation uncovered a concerning combination. They found burned insulation, a damaged vent connection, and duct tape covering a ceiling opening.
After shutting off the heater, they turned to the internet for advice on what to do next.
Here's what to know
In a Reddit post on the r/hvacadvice subreddit, the homeowner described a disconnected flue and B-vent, the double-wall piping that carries exhaust outside.


"It seems dangerous to me and is getting out of DIY territory and I would like some advice from experts," the original poster wrote alongside photos of the carnage.
The homeowner suspected that black material coming from the roof was melted tar, possibly from inadequate clearance around the vent. Cutting away the drywall also exposed pink roof insulation that was touching the vent and visibly burned.
For households considering replacement, heat pump water heaters can use less electricity and help lower water-heating bills by moving heat into the water rather than generating all of it directly.
More background
One commenter suggested that excessive heat in the vent assembly could account for the damage. They believed the single-wall pipe was sending exhaust into the space between the double-wall pipe's layers.
"That seems super dangerous not only as a fire risk but CO as well," a commenter reacted.
The homeowner replied that the heater had been running for weeks after they purchased the house. Even after shutting it down, they were losing sleep over the discovery.
They clarified that the furnace was elsewhere in the home and had a separate vent they described as fine. The water heater's problematic vent, meanwhile, ran a short, straight path through the ranch-style house.
What can be done?
One commenter supported the homeowner's decision to shut off the heater and seek professional help.
"When it comes to things that have a high chance to burn down my house I go to the experts," they wrote. "You were correct in turning everything off."
For next steps, commenters on Reddit urged the homeowner to have a dependable HVAC professional install replacement venting. One recommended replacing the entire run with double-wall B-vent, while another called for an inspection of the water heater itself.
One commenter described using a proper single-wall-to-B-vent connector and roof components such as a storm collar and vent cap. They also noted that B-vent needs one inch of clearance from combustible materials, including at the ceiling and roof openings.
If replacement becomes part of the plan, Cala offers configurable smart heat pump water heaters. Their settings can align water-heating schedules with household demand, helping reduce energy use and bills.
For an owner reassessing an inherited installation, Cala adds operating efficiency to the replacement conversation.
Where can I learn more?
Other homeowners have also uncovered water heater venting hazards, sometimes after spotting melted parts.
• A home inspector found a running gas water heater dumping exhaust directly inside.
• A Wisconsin family shut off their heater after a roofer installed an improper vent cap.
• A homeowner spotted melting atop a heater and received an urgent carbon monoxide warning.
• Melted plastic on a 2020 water heater prompted concerns about possible backdrafting.
• Plumbers warned that a melted water heater switch signaled venting trouble after heating stopped.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.




