• Home Home

Buyer of $475,000 home flags corroded AC coils, and commenters point to dog urine as the culprit

"If you have a dog, put a fence around it (with 2ft clearance all around)."

An air conditioning unit covered with a black tarp, placed on gravel next to a wooden structure.

Photo Credit: Reddit

A homebuyer purchasing a $475,000 house discovered an unwelcome detail in the inspection report: corrosion on the outdoor air-conditioning unit.

The buyer turned to Reddit's r/HVACAdvice community to ask whether it was worth negotiating concessions. 

Here's what to know

In the Reddit thread, the original poster summarized their situation, writing, "Buying a home for $475,000. Already negotiated $7,500 in seller concessions, $1,500 on other repairs as well that have been accepted."

OP added, "Concerned about the amount of corrosion seen in the photo from our inspector. Is this something worth negotiating/having and HVAC tech out to evaluate?"

Photo Credit: Reddit

Commenters streamed into the thread to discuss the damage to the unit. Several commenters identified animal urine as the likely cause of the corroded coil fins. Their assessments ranged from warnings about premature failure to reassurance that the pictured damage was far from catastrophic.

One wrote, "The corrosion is bad but it's not the worst I've seen. The fins are still there. Gently wash the coil with water. Don't let any animal pee on it anymore. If you have a dog, put a fence around it (with 2ft clearance all around)."

Another added, "Mine was much worse (dog pee). I neutralized it, cleaned it, and it is still working fine 6 years later. Decide whether it's worth it to you to strain the deal." The OP responded to this, writing, "The unit is only 4 years old, I am worried about its longevity if this is what it looks like after 4 years. … I feel confident that something like this wouldn't strain the deal."

A third user wrote, "If you are able to use it as a negotiation tool, [it] might be a nice way to get a little money back on the deal. I personally would consider that money as insurance rather than an expected cost of repairs." 

Where can I learn more?

A damaged AC unit can raise tough questions about repairs and costs, especially when you're buying a home. 

• A Florida homeowner was told she needed two ACs before a technician found years of uncleaned coils.

• A Texas homeowner expected warranty coverage but received a $5,600 repair quote for coil work.

• A landlord questioned a $1,400 warranty-coil bill after an HVAC firm proceeded without approval.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider