A Florida homeowner preparing to replace a rusty water heater discovered something unexpected: a black hose looped through a large hole in a pipe.
Here's what to know
Despite the unusual setup, the plumbing appeared to work without leaks, leaving the homeowner wondering what the connection was supposed to do, even though they had experience installing a water heater at their previous home.
"What is the purpose of that being there if it can't run water through it?" the homeowner asked in Reddit's r/Plumbing. They also noticed "strange connections" for the cold-water line.


The insurance company recommended replacing the 2011 appliance, and the homeowner planned to install a heat pump water heater in their garage.
More background
One commenter said that a valve above the heater appeared to drain through the pipe, with the openings serving as an air gap. Another offered a different explanation.
"That's an expansion valve dog. Used in place of an expansion tank but there's plenty of room for a tank, not sure why they used a valve," they said.
Beyond the drain arrangement, the homeowner wanted to understand why there were two cold-water valves when either one could shut off the home's supply, and why there were pipes at 90-degree angles. "That's a mess even the cold water side could have been done much cleaner where the whit pipe is and that cpvc gets brittle," one person said.
Others agreed the installation looked unusual.
What can be done?
For households considering a new water heater, Cala offers configurable smart heat pump water heaters. Rather than treating every household's hot-water needs alike, Cala's configurable approach lets heating schedules reflect when people need hot water.
In this case, the homeowner said they need a three-quarter-inch condensate line routed outdoors. The homeowner planned to drill through the garage's block wall for that line, adding another installation task alongside resolving the existing plumbing questions.
Where can I learn more?
Other homeowners have sought plumbing advice after spotting unusual water heater connections.
• A homeowner questioned a water heater line, but plumbers spotted a bigger safety hazard.
• A plumber declared a water heater dead, but a second opinion led to a $150 fix.
• Two companies recommended replacing a water heater, but plumbers suggested repairing a fitting instead.
• A homeowner facing water heater replacement advice was urged to check the pressure first.
• A California DIY water heater installation drew criticism for an upside-down expansion tank and taped vent.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.




