• Home Home

New Jersey couple's first furnace tune-up ends with a shutdown and $10,000 replacement quote

Combustion gases could enter the home's airflow and circulate.

A camera display screen showing a picture of a furnace.

Photo Credit: Reddit

A New Jersey couple's first furnace tune-up after moving into their home brought an unexpected setback.

Here's what to know

On Reddit, the homeowner explained that the HVAC expert they called "red tagged" the system, which the homeowner assumed meant "switch off and don't use" it, and they faced an estimate of about $10,000 for a replacement furnace, or roughly $25,000 to replace the air conditioner as well. 

The original poster was new to the United States and wanted to know whether their 13-year-old furnace actually needed replacing and whether the proposed price was reasonable. The couple had already arranged for a professional second opinion.

"Sucks to have this bad news when things are tight already at home!" the original poster wrote.

The technician's report described dirt and debris limiting airflow at the secondary heat exchanger. It also noted a dirty filter and repeated shutdowns triggered by the furnace's high-limit safety control.

The technician shut off the gas supply and the furnace's power switch after reporting multiple heat exchanger failures.

Several commenters said the posted images appeared to show damage that needed attention. Others noted that a failed heat exchanger could call for replacing the component rather than buying an entirely new furnace.

More background

The technician's report identified that combustion gases could enter the home's airflow and circulate through the registers.

One commenter said the primary and secondary heat exchangers could still qualify for a parts-only warranty, though labor would not be covered. Another disputed whether that coverage was still available.

The first commenter cautioned that a replacement heat exchanger could fail again if the underlying problem went unresolved, citing an oversized furnace or too little airflow as possible causes. 

What can be done?

Someone who said they were an HVAC company employee in Washington state suggested asking for an indoor carbon monoxide test and a combustion analysis, along with a visual inspection using a camera or removing the heat exchanger. They also urged the household to get carbon monoxide detectors if they did not already have them and to leave the condemned furnace switched off.

Commenters also recommended including smaller local contractors and businesses recommended by neighbors when gathering two or three estimates. One person warned that larger companies with prominent advertising could be substantially more expensive.

"His diagnosis is plausible, if this system went without maintenance for years the chain of reaction makes sense," the HVAC professional in the thread wrote.

Where can I learn more?

Other homeowners have found themselves weighing expensive HVAC quotes and wondering whether they really needed a replacement. 

• A widowed homeowner received a $10,000 HVAC cleaning quote, prompting commenters to question the price.

• In Wisconsin, a homeowner said a $1,900 furnace quote became a $19,000 replacement pitch within minutes.

• A Connecticut homeowner faced an $11,000 furnace replacement recommendation despite an oil technician's midlife assessment.

• A homeowner received a $14,000 furnace replacement pitch over a rusty bolt, then heard it was fine.

• A Philadelphia homeowner received a $4,900 furnace quote after carbon monoxide testing; technicians urged further testing.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider