• Home Home

Hawai'i woman says drywall left outside in rain for 50 days was installed in her new home

"The locks were changed, the water to the property was shut off."

A wall with dark mold stains and marks resembling a mountain range.

Photo Credit: iStock

A Maui woman alleges that her complaints about construction problems led to her being denied access to her new house and having its water service shut off. She said workers installed drywall that had been left on her lawn through 50 days of heavy rain.

Here's what to know

Ashley Caris, a Hawaiian Home Lands beneficiary, said she still cannot move into her three-bedroom house at Keokea Hawaiian Homestead, according to Hawaii News Now.

The post-and-pier home has a painted exterior, a maintained lawn, and panoramic mountain-to-ocean views.

Caris said the nonprofit contractor's employees knew about the drywall problem by July. She alleges the contractor had left the material outside starting in April, and that employees and volunteers installed it despite noticing water damage when they opened the bundles in June.

By August, she said, "Green and grey fuzzy substances started growing on the textured drywall now in the house," Hawaii News Now reported.

The contractor told Hawaii News Now that the house passed inspections and that it had discarded mold-affected material.

More background

The nonprofit acknowledged that delays began early in construction of Caris' Kula home and that the project was taking longer than expected. The nonprofit said it has helped local residents construct over 125 affordable, safe homes during its 28 years of work.

The organization acknowledged the frustration caused by construction delays and cited the August 2023 wildfires as a major disruption. The nonprofit said the fires destroyed 10 of its Lahaina homes, and its team organized assistance for families impacted by the disaster.

Caris alleges she faced retaliation for raising concerns about the project. She also said workers damaged electrical equipment.

"The locks were changed, the water to the property was shut off, and staff started telling me that I'm not allowed to be up here," she said.

What's being done?

The contractor said it asked outside professionals to evaluate the issues Caris reported and recommend corrective steps.

The nonprofit told Hawaii News Now that it had followed the professionals' recommendations. Its statement also said multiple pieces of material were discarded after visible mold was found on them.

Caris, however, disputes the proposed response.

"The proposed remedy from Habitat is to paint over the mold that's on the walls," she said. "When we have multiple documents stating otherwise."

Caris has submitted complaints to state authorities and to the Better Business Bureau. She also challenged the nonprofit's explanation of its wildfire response. She said that helping Lahaina families and fulfilling existing construction contracts both deserve the organization's time and resources.

Despite the dispute, Caris emphasized that she wants a resolution with the contractor.

"I never wanted this process to come this far," she said. "We thought we would be able to remedy the situation between myself as owner and Habitat as contractor, but we're at the point where we need assistance and resolution."

Where can I learn more?

Other homebuyers have faced disputes over construction quality, moisture damage, and mold. These stories follow buyers dealing with unfinished construction, rain leaks, high moisture readings, and unexpected home defects.

• A California homebuyer was rushed into inspecting an unfinished house, then told to wait 11 months.

• In New Mexico, rain exposed six leaks after a buyer's inspection raised no major concerns.

• A buyer found a 999 moisture reading in a renovated home, prompting blunt warnings.

• A first-time buyer faced roof, HVAC, mold, and sewer surprises, prompting warnings to walk away.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider