New York State officials have warned that artificial intelligence is making holiday shopping scams look far more credible, and existing advice to identify them is quickly becoming obsolete.
For shoppers seeking affordable gifts, that means fake retailers and bogus celebrity endorsements are becoming harder to distinguish from the real thing, Newsday reported.
Here's what to know
"Just assume that everything is a scam from the start, and then work backward," said Katie Sherwin, director of New York's Division of Consumer Protection.
"We can't depend on some of the old advice about looking for misspellings or poorly fabricated old websites," she added, citing standing advice about spotting scams.
Counterfeit merchandise and goods that fall short of their advertising are two of the potential risks, while in other cases, nothing arrives at all.
Scams involving internet purchases and sellers are New York's most prevalent frauds, particularly around the holidays, Sherwin told Newsday.
Long Island consumers reported $26.3 million in scam losses in 2025, up from $24.2 million in 2024, according to Division of Consumer Protection data.
Shoppers scouring social media for affordable gifts are particularly vulnerable, Sherwin noted.
Consumers reported that apparent weight loss endorsements from celebrity Oprah Winfrey and other celebrities used fabricated videos, according to Newsday.
More than 200 complaints to the Better Business Bureau in 2025 cited social media advertisements for the weight loss supplements Lipomax and Prozenith.
More background
Holiday obligations and approaching gift deadlines can leave shoppers distracted, according to Paige Schaffer, who heads cybersecurity company Iris OnWatch.
Schaffer recalled buying a blanket from an online retailer that never delivered it.
"Time pressure forces rushed decisions without proper verification," she said.
According to the Federal Trade Commission, seemingly urgent, phony tracking prompts may pressure recipients to change their delivery or shipping settings without taking a closer look.
The agency noted that scammers often weaponize urgency to mine personal information.
Hofstra University law professor Norman Silber told Newsday that thieves can copy gift card codes before returning the compromised cards to the shelf.
Scammers can then use those stolen codes to access the money after a cashier loads funds onto a card, according to Consumer Reports.
What can be done?
Nils Mueller, the Global Anti-Scam Alliance's North America chapter director, recommends searching independently for products rather than following links in emails or on social media.
Checking reviews on third-party websites can also help shoppers vet unfamiliar sellers.
For gift cards, the District of Columbia attorney general's office recommends choosing stores that keep cards behind a register or add a barcode only at purchase.
The FTC recommends using credit cards for online shopping because of their fraud protections. Shoppers should be wary of unfamiliar sellers requesting payment through the Venmo app, gift cards, or cryptocurrency, as those transactions can be difficult to reverse.
If shoppers fall victim to an unscrupulous seller, the FTC advises them to promptly ask their bank, card issuer, or payment service whether it can reverse the transaction.
Scam reports can also be submitted at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
"We need to have defenses built up and tactics," Mueller told Newsday. "We need to talk about it so people feel like they actually have a chance here and can defend themselves."
Where can I learn more?
A tempting discount can lead shoppers to a fake retailer. These stories cover social media phishing, deceptive retail ads, and a fake Calpak storefront.
• Fake Lego and Calvin Klein discount posts can steal shoppers' card details via social media.
• Prime Deal Days shoppers were warned to verify the sellers behind bargains before buying.
• A shopper was hit with $2,000 in fraudulent charges after clicking a fake Calpak storefront.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







