The UK Department of Health and Social Care uncovered more than 90,000 fraudulent responses to a consultation on tobacco and vaping rules, revealing a very different picture of public opinion once the automated submissions were removed.
Among valid respondents, nearly 80% supported restrictions on disposable vape sales.
Here's what to know
A study published in the journal Tobacco Control examined responses to the government's 2023 consultation, according to The Independent.
The department flagged 90,835 submissions out of 118,756 as fraudulent, amounting to more than three-quarters of the total.
All but two focused on one item, rejecting limits on sales of disposable vapes.
That same number said they learned about the consultation through social media. Each automated response only contained selections from multiple-choice options.
The researchers said counting the fraudulent submissions would have made opposition to the restrictions appear to be the prevailing view.
The fraudulent submissions played no part in final decision-making: the department left them out of its consultation report.
More background
The bots' intended objective was "not known," according to the study's authors, Dr. Nason Maani of Edinburgh University and Professor Anna Gilmore of Bath University.
The researchers saw signs of a "coordinated campaign" in the uniformity and volume of the submissions.
The researchers noted that past tobacco-industry efforts to influence consultations set a precedent for submitting responses in bulk. That comparison, however, does not establish responsibility in this case.
Beyond risks to young people's health, disposable vapes contribute to environmental harm caused by single-use plastics, toxic electronic waste, and improperly discarded lithium batteries.
The study focused on interference in policymaking, however, rather than measuring the health effects or environmental damage associated with vaping.
What's being done?
Maani and Gilmore advocated better tools for identifying automated submissions and stronger procedural protections, The Independent noted.
They called for those measures as increasingly sophisticated bots threaten information gathering across different regulatory subjects and research areas.
Some lower-resource institutions may have no systems for screening submissions at all, making them a particular concern for the researchers.
"This appears to be the first documented instance of large-scale automated interference in a formal public health policy consultation," the paper reads.
Caroline Cerny, deputy chief executive of Action on Smoking and Health, discussed the issue with The Guardian.
"Evidence that AI bots have been used to swamp a Department of Health consultation is deeply concerning," she began.
"Given the tobacco industry's history of seeking to undermine public health regulation, we need to be alert to the risk that technological advances can be used to further commercial interests around health policy and put safeguards in place," Cerny continued.
"Decisions that affect public health must be based on sound evidence and expertise, not manipulated response numbers."
Where can I learn more?
Youth access, industry lobbying, and battery waste are all part of the debate over vape restrictions. These stories cover UK vape policies and fires linked to discarded vapes and batteries.
• In the UK, new vape duties have prompted some users to plan stockpiling.
• In England, discarded vapes and batteries ignited a garbage truck, sending up thick smoke.
• In Michigan, improperly discarded lithium-ion batteries sparked a 1.5-acre landfill fire.
Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.







