• Outdoors Outdoors

In Florida, a dead alligator had a hammer in its forehead, and a business owner was charged

"You would think the logical question would be why would you do it and refuse to answer?"

An alligator in a yard.

Photo Credit: iStock

A wildlife case in West Palm Beach, Florida, is drawing alarm after officers found a dead alligator with a hammer still embedded in its forehead.

Haifa Limestone owner Desmond T. Keogh was charged with two felonies and one misdemeanor in connection with the animal's death and an alleged firearms violation.

Here's what to know

According to WPBF, the case began Oct. 19 with an anonymous tip about a dead alligator in Palm Beach County. 

From there, Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission officers followed the lead to Keogh's West Palm Beach property.

According to the agency, Keogh told officers he had both shot the animal and hit it several times in the head with a hammer.

Officers found the reptile with the hammer still lodged in its forehead. Keogh appeared in Palm Beach County court, where a judge set his bond at $3,000.

In its report, FWC noted that Keogh did not hold active alligator tags, which Florida requires for anyone seeking to target, harvest, or possess an alligator. The agency also alleged that he illegally discharged a firearm in public.

"Except in cases involving an immediate public safety threat or a properly licensed and permitted hunter participating in an alligator harvest, it is illegal to kill an alligator," the FWC said in a statement. 

Authorities booked Keogh on two felonies and a misdemeanor, but court records did not address why the alligator was killed.

More background

Florida law allows such actions only in limited situations, including an immediate public safety threat or a licensed harvest.

Rules governing protected wildlife outline a process for handling potentially dangerous encounters without resorting to unlawful violence.

The case also carried a direct public safety concern, as the FWC accused Keogh of illegally firing a gun in public.

What's being done?

FWC said the investigation remains ongoing and that no additional information was available for release.

The state's permit requirements for alligator harvests, restrictions on when an animal can be killed, and criminal charges when officials believe those rules were violated are designed to channel wildlife conflicts through licensed and documented processes rather than private action.

The reason the alligator was killed is still unknown, which the judge emphasized at the hearing. 

"You would think the logical question would be why would you do it and why would you do it and refuse to answer?" they said.

Where can I learn more?

Other Florida alligator incidents show how quickly these encounters can turn into criminal investigations or public safety problems. 

• In the Everglades, video showed an influencer repeatedly shooting at an alligator, and authorities investigated.

• In Marion County, wildlife officials investigated a woman after she was filmed petting a wild alligator in Florida.

• In Venice, Florida, police moved in after a 10-foot-long alligator appeared outside a 7-Eleven.

• In the Everglades, bystanders recorded kids standing feet from a wild alligator during a reckless photo-op.

Get TCD's free newsletters for easy tips, smart advice, and a chance to earn $5,000 toward home upgrades. To see more stories like this one, change your Google preferences here.

Cool Divider